The Pop Tart Brigade


Three individuals (Charlotte, Caroline and Jon) set out to discover the best of the best Pop Tarts created by Kelloggs.

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

tart temperature and other procedure

I have noticed that the folks at headquarters are encouraging us to eat our tarts frozen.
Has anyone tried this? I feel apprehensive about eating a hot or even room temperature item preporting to simulate a milkshake. Maybe I should try the milkshake flavor frozen. But are we all supposed to try it at the same time? how does "Social" work?-Caroline

Tuesday, August 02, 2005

Frosted Blueberry

Oh yeah, now this is happening...I'm writing my first of many reviews. The first being the wonderful Frosted Blueberry, otherwise known as the frosted "bloob."

Upon opening the package I was starving, there could have been a stick of butter in that foil and I would have eaten it without complaint. However, I discovered the bloob, covered in just the right amount of frosting (which I think is standard among all frosted tarts) and just the right amount of little candy sprinkles. I had these once before, but I tried to block that from my memory.

Wow, untoasted I broke that gem into triangles and threw each piece down like I was eating my last meal. Very satisfying, in fact, I felt much like a kid again and it made me happy. I sat at my desk facing away from the crowd, hoping that I wouldn't be interrupted in this beautiful moment. Never fails, in walks my neighbor who always comes to visit when it's time to blow the nose, scratch the dry skin, or squeeze ticks out of their hair. It spoiled it for me. Something about nose-blowing in front of someone that makes me want to vomit. Sure we all do it, but we don't go visit a co-worker everytime we get an urge to clear our sinuses.

So now I associate the Frosted Bloob with nose-blowing. Gross! Never again...
Rating 2.0

Chocolate Chip

So I tried Chocolate Chip last night. I was expecting plain pastry with a chocolate filling and then chocolate icing -- because that's what the box showed. But when I opened a package, I was pleasantly surprised. The pastry was light brown in color -- it looked exactly like a chocolate chip cookie. And there were little chocolate chips imbedded in the top. There was also a drizzling of chocolate frosting (light brown in color) over the top. I wasn't very hungry when I toasted them, because I ate a big dinner, but the smell of them toasting was very good. Like chocolate chip cookies baking. I retrieved them from the toaster (burning my fingers per usual) and put them on a plate. I studied them for a little while before taking a bite. The imbedded chips had melted. So the whole thing was very similar to fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. But I took a bite of the corner and was nonplussed. The pastry didn't taste like chocolate chip cookies. It sort of lacked flavor. The chocolate icing on the top also didn't have much flavor. Then I hit the filling -- it was very shiny and dark brown. It taste like chocolate but definitely didn't taste like melted chocolate chips. I already wanted to jump ship, but figured I should press on to the middle. The middle being that point where the amount of filling is the greatest. but once I got in, I wanted out fast. I regretted every bit. I thought to myself, if I wanted a chocolate chip cookie, I would just make some. I wouldn't want or expect a pop tart to emulate a chocolate chip cookie. So I had a full tart and a 1/3 tart left. I wasn't sure what to do with them... I couldn't give them to Chouli (she only will eat the brown sugar cinnamon ones -- toasted, mind you, WITH frosting).

But then I thought oh I'll just throw them in the trash. Big problem with that, though... I have serious ants in my house. carpenter ants, sugar ants -- you name it. If it's an ant, it's been living the high life in my house. If I throw anything in my garbage, they find it, suck out any available sugary marrow, and head straight home to the large, lazy, pupated queen. They regurgitate their gift, thus propagating their family. Long story short, if I throw sugary tarts in the trash, I will have a veritable ant woodstock next morning. I once dropped a breath mint on my floor and the next day it was totally swarmed. I actually thought I saw little police ants with shields holding back the crowd.

So what did I do with the unwanted, wannabe CCC tarts? flushed em down the loo. after a few swirls, I could see them start to soften and down they went. brilliant.

so I score the Chocolate Chip Pop Tarts a 1.5. But I am sure if you are into them, they would be great. I brought the rest of the box into work today. I gave one package to Jon and put the rest of the box in accounting... -Charlotte

Monday, August 01, 2005


I am so happy to have a WildBerry experience after the degradation of Chocolate chip cookie dough and French Toast flavors. I would give raw WildBerry a 3.5 and, once toasted, it becomes a 4. In both conditions it would be nicely matched with a glass of cold milk; with the raw b/c it is so dry and with the toasted b/c it is so sweet.
It is my belief that this is a strawberry tart with wild frosting. The filling is uniformly bright red and the pastry is of the classic kind and texture but the frosting is a delightful purple swirled with blue. I think the intention is to make you think of other berries, but it reminded me of the graphics associated with that 90s classic, "Saved by the Bell." In fact, I think a cold glass of milk, a toasted WildBerry poptart and an episode of "SBTB" would be a wonderful pick-me-up. I would certianly recommend this flavor to others and would buy it again myself. Yum. -CACG

Sunday, July 24, 2005

Darth Tarts

After receiving some of the Pop Tart reviews, I inquired as to whether any of you have tried the Star Wars Darth Vader Lavaberry Pop Tarts I had previously seen at the supermarket. Charlotte said no and suggested I review these.

Since I was driving to NY today, I figured what better entertainment could I have besides That 70’s Show and a box of lava cakes at the hotel tonight. On my way home, I stopped to see if these interesting specimens were still on clearance at my local supermarket. When I previously noticed these bright red pop tarts, I was horrified. The second time I saw them, they were on clearance.I wandered around the store to the clearance section in the back and found a goldmine. Not only were the Lava berry Tarts on clearance, they had an additional flavor. Robots Wildberry Pop Tarts. These looked a little more normal, but I picked up both boxes at the bargain price.

Ok, so I got into my hotel around 11:15pm tonight and they informed me that they were overbooked, but would be glad to put me up for free at the Crowne Plaza. Really there is nothing I wanted to do more at 11:30, then drive around to another hotel. Fortunately, I sort of knew where it was and did not get lost. Yes, I walked into the Crowne Plaza in jeans and my baseball cap with a backpack and pop tarts. I could tell they were impressed.

Summerfield has a microwave and stove, Crowne Plaza does not. Tonight, I was limited to testing the Lava berry pop tarts cold. It makes me chuckle when I look at the sleep cd, lavender linen spray, ear plugs, and eye mask all wrapped up nicely in a little gift bag. I’m about to eat Red Star Wars Pop Tarts at midnight while I watch TV.

The box has Star Wars trivia and quotes on it. As I’ve seen only 1 old Star Wars movie and Revenge of the Sith, I don’t really recognize any of the quotes or know any answers. The actual envelope is generic silver. Perhaps this is to obscure the pop tart horror that is inside and trick us into opening the package. The pop tarts themselves are not nearly as bright red as the picture on the box. It is more like a cross between a brick and creamy tomato soup. The frosting is slightly darker and there are strange circular (hole punch sized) orange and yellow swirled sprinkle things. In opinion, they look kind of like a jackolantern puked on top.

My first bite was the corner. I don’t believe there was any frosting or filling. It tasted kind of like soap with the chemical red dye taste, slightly reminiscent of those nasty pink butter cookies that are shaped like leaves with flavorless chocolate holding them together. (I realize you may not have seen these disgusting cookies before, but my mom liked to purchase them for special occasions.)

Bite #2 had frosting, sprinkles, and filling. It was slightly sweet and possibly berry like, mixed with the chalky, red dye soap taste. As I was almost done chewing it, my teeth hit one of the extra large sprinkles. They are pretty solid and sound like, when you bite into a smartie. I’m not sure they lend any special facets to this taste abomination. Though I was tempted to break into a chorus of “crunch, crunch, crunch, ohhhhhhhhh…crunch, crunch crunch”, each time I bit into one. (You may need to seek an explanation of this from Charlotte if you have not witnessed this interaction with Chouli.) Further bites tasted slightly salty along with the soap/berry flavor. I’m going to wash this down with the remainder of my complimentary bottled water.

Friday in White Plains, I will try microwaving one of the Darth Tarts to see if cooking helps to neutralize any of the odd flavors. Perhaps, nuking the lava berries will morph them into a much better tasting product. I suppose it is safe to suspect that molten lava berries would taste better than solid ones, just because. At the current time, I would only give these 1.5 light sabers out of 5. Perhaps, they should have used the force when making them.

I’m still left with 5 packs of Darth Tarts. If anyone is brave enough to try some, I could send some in the overnight. Otherwise, I will leave them in the kitchen. People in Dedham will eat anything.

Update: I microwaved it for 1 minute. This was perhaps too long, I don't know as I never cooked a pop tart before. (I prefer the raw strawberry tarts)

After one minute the darth tart exploded and began smoking. I believe some of yellow/orange sprinkles became molten sugar rocks. The molten lava berry filling oozed out of the side while smoke billowed from the top. (I'm totally serious!)

I poured water on it, to cool it down then deposited in the closest trash receptacle. I'll try again at home tonight.

Molten darth tarts smell like pancakes. - Jo (guest panelist)

Thursday, July 21, 2005

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough poptart was not a success raw. the filling was a dried out vanilla pudding dotting with jimmies. raw this tasted a lot like homemade paste. the frosting was chocolate with swirls of vanilla and was delicious. i like that it is crackly. but overall i thought the whole thing would be better toasted.i had imagined that the filling would become molten when toasted, like an undercooked cookie. but now it is just warm paste. this pop tart is not delicious. i would give it a 2 (because the frosting was so good) and never buy it again. - Caroline

Wednesday, July 20, 2005

Frosted Rasperry

I was really excited about the frosted raspberry. I anticipated red filling with white frosting. I was also excited about the raspberry flavor, because the only two fruit flavors of PT I have experienced were blueberry and strawberry. Well, the frosted raspberry did indeed have a bright red filling, but it was definitely too bright, too red -- like they added too much of that carcinogenic Red No. 5. The frosting was white and I noticed that when it was toasting (after the blueberry experience I am sorry to say I have very little desire to try another untoasted tart of any flavor), the flecks of red candy imbedded in the frosting were bubbling and sizzling -- some even jumped ship and plummeted to a sizzling, fiery death in my toaster. So I was pretty excited. MUCH to my chagrin, I was sorely disappointed. The filling and those little red candies on top were WAY too sweet (so sweet my teeth hurt), too red, too much like candy. Unlike like plain strawberry (still my favorite), which retains some semblance of hearty-crisp-pastry-with-semi-real-fruit-filling, the frosted raspberry was an abomination of sugar and fake colors. I score it a 2.5. I almost didn't want to finish the box of them (but you know I did). - Charlotte

Tuesday, July 19, 2005

Plain Blueberry

I have tried plain blueberry many times in the past and often cite is as one of my top two tarts (plain strawberry being the other). however, this may be due to the fact that, for a long time, those were the only two I ever tried. Anyway, I bought a box at Hannaford at lunchtime the other day. Appreciating Caroline's recommendation that raw tarts must be given due testing, I wolfed down both raw tarty blubes before I got back to the office (which is only about 2 minutes away). I found that I didn't enjoy unfrosted pastry as much untoasted. and while I usually love those crispy little corners, these corners just tasted lardy and cold. It also left a weird, chemical aftertaste in my mouth. the insides were cold but still nice and tarty and tasted vaguely of real blueberries (I have bushes and bushes of luscious blueberries at home that are currently ripe, so I now what I be sayin here).but then I ate two more packages (or was it three) that night toasted (I'm know, I'm a gluttinous pig), and they were exceptional. I rate the plain blueberry poptarts a solid 4 on the PTart scale. Untoasted, they are not even worth rating. - Charlotte